|
Elderflower
A Chinese Medicine Perspective
Peter Holmes, L.Ac., M.H.
© Peter Holmes 2004
The
elder tree is a familiar sight in both town and country, and a good seasonal
marker. It is said that the 'English summer is not here until the elder
is fully in flower, and that it ends when the berries are ripe' (Grieve
1971). This common pan-European tree with its 'flat-topped masses of creamy-white,
fragrant blossoms', has provided several traditional herbal remedies since
prehistoric days: Elder flower, berry, bark and leaf. The most versatile
and widely used of these, however, is the flower, which therefore deserves
a fresh look as a potential neo-Chinese medicinal herb. Elderflower is
the whole flower corymb of Sambucus nigra in the honeysuckle (Caprifoliaceae)
family. Its pharmaceutical name is Flos sambuci (using the Chinese method
of pharmaceutical nomenclature).
The
traditional European usage of Elderflower is centered around its ability
to promote sweating (diaphoresis) and its specific affinity for the respiratory
tract. Its primary indications are the onset of colds and flus, especially
with fever present, as well as bronchitis and asthma (Weiss 1985, Schauenberg
1977 et al.). With the rise of the toxicosis and elimination theories
in Western herbal medicine during the seventeenth centuries, its diaphoretic
action has also been put to service to promote general detoxification,
i.e. toxin elimination (Valnet 1983, Willfort 1986). In North America
Eclectic doctors also utilised Elderflower's diuretic, anti-inflammatory
and depurative actions for chronic edema and urinary and skin infections
in particular (King 1902, Fyfe 1909 et al.). More recent physiomedical
usage in America and England has also included application for acute upper
respiratory discharges (Lyle 1897, Mills 1978) because of its pronounced
anticatarrhal or mucostatic effect.
Since
time immemorial, Elderflower has provided countless cherished culinary
and domestic medicine products, both in England and overseas, including
elderflower wine, cordial, vinegar (for sore throat), floral water (for
eye and skin lotions) and ointment (for skin conditions). The berries
too have been made into syrups, purees or robs, jams, jellies, chutneys
and kechups. Many of the recipes for these originated in the Tudor still-rooms
of larger households. Maud Grieve devotes a full 11 pages to the many
traditional uses of the elder tree in construction, ritual, medicine and
cooking, setting out with the statement that 'a wealth of folk-lore, romance
and superstition centre round this English tree'. I would refer the reader
to this excellent compilation for further information-and recipes-in these
various areas.
Energetic
Properties and Functions
As regards its toxicity category, Elderflower is considered a mild remedy
that possesses minimal to no chronic cumulative toxicity. It may therefore
safely be used over long periods of time, all the more so as it will be
combined-more often than not-with other herbs in a formula.
The
taste is pungent, sweet and somewhat aromatic. Pungent and aromatic give
it the potential for dispersing pathogens and promoting sweating, as well
as for activating the Qi and transforming phlegm and damp. Meanwhile,
its sweet taste allows it to strengthen the Spleen and drain damp.
The
warmth/thermal quality is cool. As a light flower, its directional tendency
is floating upwards (fu) when drunk hot, allowing it to enter the Lung,
diffuse Lung Qi and then disperse the surperficies and expel pathogens.
Its floating movement also means that it can treat local problems in the
skin, eyes and upper regions in general, such as fire toxin symptoms and
rashes. When taken at room temperature or cold, however, its Qi tendency
is definitely more neutral and moderate, and includes a draining action
on water and damp-heat through the Spleen and Bladder.
The
channels entered are the Lung, Spleen and Bladder. In terms of the three
warmers (san jiao), Elderflower actually affects all three warmers, although
it is most pronounced in the upper and lower warmers. In the upper warmer
it disperses wind and heat pathogens from the surface, and transforms
phlegm, damp and Qi stagnation in the Lung with its pungent-aromatic quality.
In the lower warmer the herb clears heat and drains damp through its sweet
property.
These
qualities and essential actions in concert now provide us with grounding
for a modern application of this herb in Chinese medicine.
Clinical
Functions and Indications
1.
Releases the exterior, dispels wind-heat and stops discharge
Elderflower eliminates external pathogens with its pungent and
aromatic properties that enter the Lung channel. The mechanism of this
is by causing sweating to release the exterior. This is its strongest
action. Cooling by nature, Elderflower treats external wind-heat, particularly
with fever, nasal discharge and congestion, and sore throat. The nasal
discharge and congestion could be described as damp-heat invading the
head, and it would not be wrong to say that Elderflower actually dispels
wind-damp-heat in the exterior.
Unfortunately
there is no exact equivalent in the Chinese materia medica to this first
action. On one hand Elderflower is an unequivocal external wind-heat herb
like Ju Hua (Fl. Chrysanthemi), Jin Yin Hua (Fl. Lonicerae), etc.-all
of them flowers too-that adresses typical wind-heat symptoms. On the other
hand, this herb has the additional specific function of stopping nasal
discharges that are due to damp and heat invading the sinus passages.
In that sense it acts like a cooling version of Cang Er Zi (Fr. Xanthii)
and Xin Yi Hua (Gemma Magnoliae), but with a far greater emphasis on drying
up the discharges (rather than opening the sinuses, as in the case of
these two herbs).
Western
combining herbs for external wind-heat with just fever and sore throat
include Yarrow (Hb. Achilleae) and Linden (Fl. Tiliae). For wind-heat
with damp-heat nasal discharge, Eyebright (Hb. Euphrasiae) and Plantain
(Fm. Plantaginis) are good choices. Note here that the old Western standby
combination of Peppermint, Yarrow and Elderflower for the onset of colds
actually is somewhat of a catch-all formula that adresses external wind-cold
as well as wind-heat (Peppermint being the main wind-cold agent here)-although
it works better, on the whole, for external wind-heat because of the two
relaxant diaphoretics Yarrow and Elderflower.
Because
of its great tropism for the Lung, and as it dispels wind-heat, Elderflower
is also appropriate for Lung wind-heat syndromes with fever, sore throat
and cough, where it could be combined with such similar herbs as Burdock
seed Niu Bang Zi (Fr. Arctii), Bo He (Hb. Menthae haplocalycis), Spearmint
(Fm. Menthae spicatae) and White horehound (Hb. Marrubii).
Elderflower
is traditionally also used for treating fevers in general. It works best
in most fevers that are still in the early stages, when the skin is dry.
Elderflower can break the fever by causing sweating, including Qi-level
heat or 'warm fevers' in the early-stages (see also below).
2.
Dries damp, transforms phlegm and diffuses Lung Qi
Pungent, aromatic and dispersing, and focusing on the Lung, Elderflower
also dries damp and transforms phlegm in the upper warmer, while at the
same time regulating Lung Qi to dispel the Qi accumulation resulting from
the stagnant damp-phlegm excess. It therefore treats sputum production
and cough from phlegm-damp in the Lung, while relieving the wheezing from
the Qi accumulation in the Lung.
In
this sense Elderflower is both like Ban Xia (Rz. Pinelliae praeparata)
(for transforming phlegm-damp) and like Xuan Fu Hua (Fl. Inulae) or Bai
Qian (Rx. et rz. Cynanchi) (for regulating Lung Qi and dispersing Qi accumulation).
The only difference here is that Elderflower is cooling, not warming.
Again, unfortunately here there is no exact TCM equivalent.
Similar
Western herbs that offer combining possibilities here include the equally
aromatic herbs Thyme (Hb. Thymi) and Hyssop (Hb. Hyssopi) (with pronounced
phlegm-damp). With wheezing and coughing present, Coltsfoot (Hb. Tussilaginis)
and White horehound (Hb. Marrubii) would be more appropriate.
Because
it is both heat-clearing and dispersing, Elderflower can also be also
useful in Lung phlegm-heat patterns with Qi accumulation present. Typical
symptoms adressed here would be fever, sputum, wheeze and cough, where
it will benefit from similar-acting herbs such as Gua Lou (Fr. Tricosanthis),
Dong Gua Ren (Sm. Benincasae), Zhu Ru (Cs. Phyllostachis), White horehound
(Hb. Marrubii) and Pleurisy root (Rx. Asclepiadis tuberosae). Note here
that although Elderflower is useful for Lung wind-heat and Lung phlegm-heat
patterns, which include the symptom of cough, it does not actually expel
phlegm or stop coughing (nor do these three Chinese herb examples). It
simply transforms phlegm-damp, moderately clears heat and diffuses the
stagnant Lung Qi.
Likewise,
note also that Elderflower could not be said to descend Lung Qi in the
sense of Xing Ren (Sm. Pruni armeniacae), Bai Qian (Rx. et rz. Cynanchi)
or Sang Bai Pi (Cx. radicis Mori). These herbs posess a much stronger
action which expresses itself as downward moving and therefore strongly
wheeze and cough relieving. Elderflower is just not in this league. We
should think of Elderflower simply as a gentle yet effective Qi mover
in the Lung when either wind, phlegm or heat pathogens obstruct Qi flow-as
simple as that. This is why Elderflower is excellent for treating mild
cases, for when two or more of these pathogens are present, as well as
for treating children in general.
3.
Strengthens the Spleen, promotes urination and drains damp
With its sweet taste quality, and when drunk cold, Elderflower can drain
accumulation of water-damp and relieve edema by strengthening the Spleen.
It mainly treats chronic edema, particularly around the waist or generalised
water retention in the tissues, arising from Spleen Qi deficiency. Here
the clear equivalents are the sweet-bland herbs Fu Ling (Scm. Poriae)
or Fu Ling Pi (Cx. Poriae), Yi Yi Ren (Sm. Coicis) and Ze Xie (Rz. Alismatis).
Western possibilities include Nettle (Hb. Urticae), Goldenrod (Hb. Solidaginis),
Juniper (Fr. Juniperi) and Lovage (Rx. Levistici), although the last two
are warming, not cooling.
4.
Clears heat, drains damp and harmonizes urination
Elderflower also has an excellent affinity for the urinary tract, the
Bladder. Being heat clearing and damp transforming, the herb is also indicated
for Bladder damp-heat syndromes, including those presenting strangury
or otherwise difficult urination, and including those seen in damp and
Stone lin syndromes.
Similar
Chinese herbs for this clinical function include Che Qian Zi (Sm. Plantaginis),
Mu Tong (Cs. Akebiae seu Aristlochiae) and Bian Xu (Hb. Polygoni avicularis),
while Western additions might include Horsetail (Hb. Equiseti), Cleavers
(Hb. Galii) and Goldenrod (Hb. Solidaginis).
Elderflower
can also be chosen for damp-heat syndromes that present urinary stones
and irritation, and in this sense is a good damp-heat drainer for the
lower warmer in general, like Che Qian Zi (Sm. Plantaginis). Other suitable
herbs here include Shi Wei (Fm. Pyrrosiae), Jin Qian Cao (Hb. Lysimachiae)
and Dong Kui Zi (Sm. Abutili seu Malvae); while Cleavers (Hb. Galii),
Hydrangea (Rz. Hydrangeae) and Gravel root (Rx. Eupatorii purpureii) provide
some Western options.
5.
Clears fire toxin and benefits the skin
This last function divides into three main clinical applications.
First,
fire toxin such as boils, ulcers, abscesses, especially when found in
the upper regions (remember this is a dispersing and floating herb). Chinese
equivalents here include (once again) Jin Yin Hua (Fl. Lonicerae), Lian
Qiao (Fr. Forsythiae) and Ye Ju Hua (Fl. Chrysanthemi indici); while Western
possibilities include Marigold (Fl. Calendulae) and Echinacea (Rx. Echinaceae).
Second,
fire toxin with eye inflammations. Good equivalents for this usage include
Selfheal Xia Ku Cao (Spica Prunellae) and Ye Ju Hua (Fl. Chrysanthemi
indici); as well as Camomile (Fl. Matricariae seu Anthemis) and Eyebright
(Hb. Euphrasiae).
Third,
fire toxin and/or damp-heat in the skin causing chronic eczema (pustular,
suppurative) and ulcers. Similar herbs here include Bai Xian Pi (Cx. radicis
Dictamni), Di Fu Zi (Fr. Kochiae) and Ku Shen (Rx. Sophorae flavescentis);
as well as Red clover (Fl. Trifolii), Burdock (Rx. Arctii) and Walnut
leaf and hull (Fm. et pm. Juglandis) among Western options.
Elderflower
and Jin Yin Hua (Fl. Lonicerae) are both in the botanical honeysuckle
family, so it is worth pausing for a moment to see whether this natural
link will translate to a therapeutic connection that may be useful as
a mnemonic aid, if nothing else. Certainly, we have seen that Jin Yin
Hua has equivalent functions in many of Elderflowers'. But exactly how
far do their similarities extend, and where do their functions clearly
diverge?
As
flowers both herbs are clearly similar in their sweet, light and floating
qualities; however Jin Yin Hua is cold, whereas I consider Elderflower
cool. Both flowers release the exterior to dispel wind-heat, and both
clear fire toxin. However, Elderflower releases the exterior mainly through
causing sweating, whereas Jin Yin Hua does so mainly through clearing
heat and dispelling toxin-or, in microbial terms, through a stronger anti-infective
action. In this sense, the two would form an excellent mutual assistance
(xiang shi) if not mutual enhancement (xiang xu) combination for treating
wind-heat onsets. For treating fire toxin conditions, Elderflower treats
more superficial, milder and upper-region heat toxin (such as eye infections),
whereas Jin Yin Hua treats more internal and more severe fire toxin such
as intestinal abscesses, severe sore throat from laryngitis, and so on.
Also, Elderflower treats damp-heat skin lesions (in common with its theme
of transforming damp), unlike Jin Yin Hua. Here again, the two would form
a nice duo.
Would
Elderflower also treat Qi-level heat in early-stage warm fevers, like
Jin Yin Hua? Provided this was a dry fever/heat without sweating, yes
definitely. Being still in the beginning stage with a rising temperature,
Elderflower would easily break the fever by causing sweating.
And
here their functions part ways. Elderflower with its dispersing energy
goes on to transform phlegm-damp and 'ventilate' the Lung, as well as
drain water-damp and Bladder damp-heat. Jin Yin Hua on the other hand,
with its colder nature moves to the nutritive and Blood level to clear
the heat of epidemic warm fevers. In summary, I would say that Elderflower
is better at releasing the exterior, while Jin Yin Hua is better at clearing
fire toxin.
Precautions
Elderflower is a mild remedy with no chronic toxicity and may
be used freely. However, because it promotes sweating when drunk warm
or hot, contraindicated in sweating from external deficiency or Yin deficiency
(like Ma Huang, in fact), and in Qi-level heat with sweating already present.
Preparation
The basic preparation for releasing exterior conditions is the hot water
infusion. Because this preparation is dispersing, it is excellent (with
or without other wind-heat dispelling herbs-see above) for releasing the
exterior at the onset of symptoms. The cool or cold infusion is preferable
for all other uses, which engages a more descending effect.
Elderflower
can also be given in the convenient tincture form and is available as
such from various suppliers. The tincture is an alternative to the cold
infusion for its other functions, as this is more activating on the interior.
When
used in conjunction with a decoction formula, such as Yin Qiao San or
Cang Er Zi San, Elderflower can be added 5 minutes before the end of decocting
time or, better still, stirred into the hot finished decoction and allowed
to infuse for another 15 minutes with the lid on before straining. Elderflower
does contain an essential oil that will evaporate in the decocting or
infusing process if the lid is not put on!
Local
preparations with Elderflower for fire toxin symptoms, such as eyewashes,
skin compresses, creams, ointments, and so on, are also good options in
adition to internal intake. Topical and internal administration will always
reinforce each other's action.
Remarks
Elderberry (Fr. Sambuci) has similar qualities to the flower and can be
used in a short decoction, especially to dispel wind-damp obstruction
and open the bowels. Because modern research has shown Elderberry specifically
to possess antiviral properties, it is today an important remedy for viral
onset of flu. Elderberry can be used preventively in case of a flu pandemic,
and when taken during an infection has shown to speed up recovery time.
The flower and the berry can of course always be used together in external
conditions.
Elder
bark (Cx. Sambuci) (using the inner bark) strongly drains downward. In
a decoction it strongly drains water-damp (for edema) and purges accumulation
(for severe constipation).
Dosage
The dosage is average: 6-16 g for the hot infusion; 2-5 ml for the tincture.
References
Bergzabern, Johann Jakob Theodor von (1588). Neu Kreuterbuch. Francfurth
am Main
Fuchs,
Leonhardt (1542). De Historia Stirpium. Basel
Fyfe,
John W. Specific Medication (1909). Cincinnatti, Scudder Bros.
Grieve,
Maud (1971). A Modern Herbal. London: Dover
Holmes,
Peter (1997). The Energetics of Western Herbs, 3rd revised edition. Boulder,
Snow Lotus Press
Holmes,
Peter (2003). The T.C.M. Materia Medica Clinical Reference and Study Guide.
Boulder, Snow Lotus Press
King,
John, Felter, H. and Lloyd, U. (1898). King's American Dispensatory. Cincinnati,
Scudder Bros.
Lyle,
T.J. (1897). Physiomedical Therapeutics, Materia Medica and Pharmacy.Cincinnati,
Physiomedical College
Mattioli,
Pierandrea (ed. J. Verzascha) (1611). Kreutterbuch. Basel
Mills, Simon (1978). N.I.M.H. Pharmacology Lectures. Tunbridge Wells,
N.I.M.H.
Schauenberg,
Paul, and F. Paris (1977). Guide to Medicinal Plants. New Canaan, Inner
Traditions
Valnet,
Jean (1983). Phytotherapie. Paris, Maloine
Weiss, Fritz (1985). Lehrbuch der Phytotherapie, 6th revised edition.
Stuttgart, Hippokrates
Willfort,
Richard (1986). Gesundheit durch Heilkraeuter. Linz
|